Or you get rich people who skate like GW Bush. Who technically did his 'service'. But it was made damned sure he was at next to no risk, and maximum comfort, while doing it.
Service Guarantees Citizenship: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Fascism
- Thread starter Cutlass
- Start date
Or you get rich people who skate like GW Bush. Who technically did his 'service'. But it was made damned sure he was at next to no risk, and maximum comfort, while doing it.
Zkribbler
Deity
Hmmm. I wonder what /Thomas Jefferson would say about this?
Yet today, some people claim we are not equal and that our rights are not innate but rather originate from the government. They urge that we have no rights until we serve our government.They urge that poverty be adjudged a crime, and that the poor should be punished for their poverty. The advocates fail to understand rights, humanity, and freedom.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,601
Starship Troopers is probably one of my favourite films, such an epic satire of Fascism in general. One of my favourite aspects of the film is how Americanized the whole planet is - large parts of the film takes place in Buenos Aires yet the vast majority of people are white. The few latino people there are very American in culture as well. The few scenes we get of other planets and Geneva imply that this isn't a phenomenon localised to Buenos Aires either.
Military service doesn't become more valid as it gets muddier and bloodier. It's all very well to say that all arms exist to support the infantry, but the metaphor cuts both ways - a structure with no supports isn't good for much.
Zkribbler
Deity
Through out Latin America, the ruling elites are white.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,601
Well that just goes to show how little I know about South America. I should really do my research next time.
Still, I feel like he was making a point by turning that city into a place pretty much indistingishable from Genericsville, CA.
Afaik Buenos Aires has a lot fewer non-white people than other south american large cities (?). It doesn't have a black large minority like brazilian cities do, nor (afaik) loads of citizens with native or native-colonist ancestry?
At least going by Borges, the peon and gaucho were rare in the cities while more populous in the "Pampa" plains. And the ethnic minorities were european new immigrants, such as italians.
At least going by Borges, the peon and gaucho were rare in the cities while more populous in the "Pampa" plains. And the ethnic minorities were european new immigrants, such as italians.
Thorgalaeg
Deity
Argentinean people are mostly white: spanish, italians, irish, german... There are an indigenous basis like in any latin american country but it is much more diluted in Argentina. I would say the most prevalent is italian ancestry since the huge italian migration wave happened back in early 20th-century
KmDubya
King
I have no problem with people being on welfare having life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. All of that doesn't require a vote in how the government is run.
Regardless in the book it requires military service, and has nothing to do with welfare. A poor person could volunteer the same as a rich person.
My point about limiting the vote was to perhaps get a better electorate involved in the whole process rather than the current popularity contest. Why should the people just along for the ride have as much of a say as the people pulling the sled? Eventually everyone ends up riding on the sled with no one pulling and you get nowhere.
BvBPL
Pour Decision Maker
As in RoboCop and Total Recall, Verhoeven used Starship Troopers as vehicle to comment upon state control. The film is most certainly about a rollicking bug hunt. It is also most certainly about state control of the media, the glorification of war, and fascism generally.
Bugfatty300
Buddha Squirrel
Well the plot of the Siege is resolved by constitutionally-loyal government agents and troops who refuse to follow illegal orders. You should watch it since it has something to say about the injustice and immorality of state-sponsored extrajudicial murder.
Zkribbler
Deity
Liberty certainly does. Probably life too, since no one will vote your best interests better than you.
Imo, the film is so comedic that it would be about equally clean to examine fascism in Street Fighter2
So no one gets to vote since everyone gets some form of welfare? Or everyone gets to vote since everyone pays some form of taxes?
Of course it does. The people who have traditionally not had a say in government have been slaves and (until some point in the 20th century) women. Well, I am a woman, but I'm no slave. I refuse to be anyone's compliant doormat, including the government's.
And only poor people vote on the basis of popularity instead of on the basis of the issues, the party's platform, and whether the candidate can string a coherent sentence together?
Somehow, that fails to explain the number of wealthy people who support Trump and how he got so many billionaires among his cabinet and advisers.
Should the mentally challenged be allowed to vote? That one has always been a bothersome one for me. Besides the obvious issue of just who or how that determination is made. My brain usually tells me that they don't really understand or know what is best, while my heart says that shouldn't matter.
Define "mentally challenged." My father has the right to vote, even though he has dementia. All that is necessary is that he provide proof of identity and residence, and that if he wants, he can have someone to help him - formally known as a Friend of Incapacitated Elector - to do what is necessary - read him the ballot, mark the ballot as he directs, etc. The helper must also be an eligible voter and provide proof of ID and residence. There is a bit more paperwork to it, but it's a right that he has. When I worked for Elections Canada, I had to guide a few people through this process.
Similar threads
