None Shall Pass [Game Thread - Concluded]

[Camikaze]

As much as I'd like to blame our loss on other people not trusting us, I suppose it's largely our fault for being so open without ensuring we'd secured that trust. We also probably missed a good opportunity with our failure to convert a LOTR person.

@Jarrema - lucky for you that we didn't end up converting you, I guess.

 

[BSmith1068]

This was a great game that seemed to always have a different faction in the lead. No sooner than one side thought they might be comfortable, then something happened to change the stakes entirely.

 

[Double A]

Remember that one org game where town was Chinese commie revolutionaries and GH was a SK and led the town?

 

[Arakhor]

You know, after reading the Dead QT, there were several things I could have done, but I'm glad that things went well as it was.

 

[Stuck in Pi]

Damn that was sooooo close. Great game everybody, and a huge thank you to Zack for hosting it. Surprised I almost was able to pull it out, despite me hitting every major roadblock conceivable between getting injured by Double A for two nights and trying to flip the ONE SW player that was not a legal option. Damn you, Frozen in Ice.

 

[spaceman98]

Now, vote: Niccolò-supper Machiavelli, busser of Morgoth, mega-cult, Arakhor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[spaceman98]

also http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?p=12853872&highlight=game#post12853872 This was the first mafia game ever with perfect activity. congratulations guys!

 

[Frozen In Ice]

Damn that was sooooo close. Great game everybody, and a huge thank you to Zack for hosting it. Surprised I almost was able to pull it out, despite me hitting every major roadblock conceivable between getting injured by Double A for two nights and trying to flip the ONE SW player that was not a legal option. Damn you, Frozen in Ice.

You managed to ruin the LOTR cult's chances as well, so we ended up taking each other out. When you switched from King Morgan to Takhisis for the lynch that one day you doomed us to defeat, while if you hadn't done that our cult could've won in only three more days.

Silly Takhisis with his ability upgrade claim.

 

[JohannaK]

also http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?p=12853872&highlight=game#post12853872 This was the first mafia game ever with perfect activity. congratulations guys!

 

[Jarrema]

@Jarrema - lucky for you that we didn't end up converting you, I guess.

yeah

 

[Darth Feather]

All hail to the high king of the Noldor

here is my role PM:

Elrond

Alignment:

Team:

​

Elrond Half-elven, Lord of Rivendell, was one of the mighty rulers of old who lived in Middle-earth from the First Age to the Third Age.

Day Actions:

1. Vote to lynch someone.


Night Actions:

1. You may use one active ability.



Active Abilities:

Spoiler :

Scan III - Scan another player to see one of their abilities; cannot penetrate cover roles.

Scan III, Level 2 - Scan another player to see who visits them that night.

Scan IV - Scan another player to determine the name of their role; cannot pierce cover roles.

Passive Abilities:

Spoiler :

(none)

VICTORY CONDITIONS:

Spoiler :

TOTAL VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. You and at least three other members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


MAJOR VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. You survive to the end of the game.


VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. At least three members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


CLOSE VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. Two or less members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


CLOSE DEFEAT:

You survive to the end of the game, but the Lord of the Rings Town is eliminated.


DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is eliminated.


MAJOR DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is the first team eliminated.


TOTAL DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is the first team eliminated by a wide margin.

[/FONT]​

 

[Zack]

JHT was active, though. He even sent orders like an hour before he asked for a replacement.

 

[Zack]

*blows at the cobwebs* My power was to vigilante-kill a Nazgûl and apparently there weren't any in the game to start with. I'm sure they're still hiding somewhere, under the backdrop... It was a great game though.

Well, originally there would be two Nazgûl in the game, the Witch-King and a generic Nazgûl, but I had to cut the latter out due to the number of sign-ups.

 

[edse]

Thanks for the game. I've been following it all the time even though i was killed early.

 

[JohannaK]

JHT was active, though. He even sent orders like an hour before he asked for a replacement.

Oh, yeah, of that I am sure.

 

[topsecret]

Thanks for the great game Zack.
Role PM:

Spoiler :

Frodo Baggins

Alignment:

Team:

​

Frodo Baggins, son of Drogo Baggins, was a Hobbit of the Shire in the Third Age. He was and is most renowned for his leading role in the Quest of the Ring in which he bore the One Ring to Mount Doom, where it was ultimately destroyed. He was a Ring-bearer, and one of the three Hobbits who sailed from Middle-earth to the Uttermost West at the end of the Third Age.

Day Actions:

1. Vote to lynch someone.


Night Actions:

1. All passive abilities are used automatically.



Active Abilities:

Spoiler :

(none)

Passive Abilities:

Spoiler :

Mason - Know the identity of Sam (The Black Knigh).

VICTORY CONDITIONS:

Spoiler :

TOTAL VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. You and at least three other members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


MAJOR VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. You survive to the end of the game.


VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. At least three members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


CLOSE VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. Two or less members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


CLOSE DEFEAT:

You survive to the end of the game, but the Lord of the Rings Town is eliminated.


DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is eliminated.


MAJOR DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is the first team eliminated.


TOTAL DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is the first team eliminated by a wide margin.

​

Random thoughts:
That's right, I was Frodo and all I had was a mason partner... no Ring, no Books, not even Hobbit dancing skills...
I'm pretty sure Zack had to do that to keep it balanced though.

Also, who killed my mason partner Edse? You ruined my only ability...

That was a great game! Good job to my fellow LOTR members! And good game Star Wars. You almost had us.

 

[KingMorgan]

Good game Zack, well hosted and great write ups.

Merry has a hard guy to play as there were no abilities only a mason with Bsmith, I was also concentrating on my demon team in the NotW, so got off to slow start. Everyone except me seemed to have some ability and was important in their own way, once the cliques formed I felt I was left out in the cold, could gain very little info apart from the public thread, frustrating at times, especially when the promised incontrovertible action from Bsmith never materialized. Then I found our QT has been comprised so I never felt I could trust my mason pal till he died and flipped town, I spent the rest of the game waiting to die. It was my first mafia game and I think I prefer the NotW format.

Spoiler :

Merry

Alignment:

Team:

​

Meriadoc Brandybuck, mostly named Merry for short, was a Hobbit, and one of Frodo's cousins and closest friends. He loved boats and ponies and had a great interest in the maps of Middle-earth. He is also one of the nine companions in The Fellowship of the Ring.

Day Actions:

1. Vote to lynch someone.


Night Actions:

1. All passive abilities are used automatically.



Active Abilities:

Spoiler :

(none)

Passive Abilities:

Spoiler :

Mason - Know the identity of Pippin (BSmith1068).

VICTORY CONDITIONS:

Spoiler :

TOTAL VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. You and at least three other members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


MAJOR VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. You survive to the end of the game.


VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. At least three members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


CLOSE VICTORY:

All enemies of the Lord of the Rings Town are eliminated. Two or less members of the Lord of the Rings Town survive to the end of the game.


CLOSE DEFEAT:

You survive to the end of the game, but the Lord of the Rings Town is eliminated.


DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is eliminated.


MAJOR DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is the first team eliminated.


TOTAL DEFEAT:

The Lord of the Rings Town is the first team eliminated by a wide margin.

​

 

[sirtommygunn]

*blows at the cobwebs* My power was to vigilante-kill a Nazgûl and apparently there weren't any in the game to start with. I'm sure they're still hiding somewhere, under the backdrop... It was a great game though.

The Witchking is a Nazgul.

 

[Takhisis]

And I didn't get to convert more, unfortunately.

Nice game! I wanna play the sequel!

 

[edse]

Also, who killed my mason partner Edse? You ruined my only ability...

@edse

#sorrynotsorry

Spoiler :

No worries. But if it turns out you nightkilled me night 2 in NOTW LI as well... then...