None Shall Pass [Game Thread - Concluded]

Dear god, 8 pages?!

Lets go with... Visorslash.
 
How should we handle the split town? Full war or what? The other town basically counts as enemies so about 20 of the 33 players are opponents.
I gasp in wonder at the depth and preciseness of your knowledge, fFoS:TheBlackKnigh.

x-post edit@Askthepizzaguy: no you're the one who's bananas!
 
I thought I had missed at least two days, then I started reading the thread.

The heck.

ATPG, I love you. But I can't sit here and read all that (of which the majority was you just being ATPG) and not have my SCUMDAR ALERT blaring loud and proud.
 
I understand your point ATPG but sometimes the shear amount of material can overwhelm poor townies. Most players have only a hour a day to absorb.

While there is some gold in your posts, it is a bit of work to sift away all the sediment... We shouldn't overwhelm townies to the point where they are excluded from public discussion.
 
I thought I had missed at least two days, then I started reading the thread.

The heck.

ATPG, I love you. But I can't sit here and read all that (of which the majority was you just being ATPG) and not have my SCUMDAR ALERT blaring loud and proud.

I doubt very much he is scum... In any case, he is a bloody poor lynch.
 
TALLY:

(Speak up if you see any errors! I will definitely not be offended or anything.)

iFzZ9S9.png
 
Hmm, I don't actually know what 'resolving' someone means in the context of Mafia games.

As foolish as it might be later in retrospect, I am willing to be persuaded otherwise by ATPG. On the other hand, if Gone3theCelt is willing to vote for himself, who am I to argue?
 
I'm not entirely sure, but I think vote: Double A tried to convert me last night and failed.
 
Yeah, this thread is even more active than those Realpolitiks of old in S&T.

If need be I can include you on my whirlwind "apology tour", and watch your vote peel off of me as well.

Why don't you tell the entire class precisely what is scummy about the content contained within my posts. A vague descriptor just isn't cutting the mustard with me today.

Well, for starters, you seem to be connecting everything back to yourself, even when it had nothing to do with you. Like post #258, (paraphrased) "War between the two towns is even worse than lynching me!" Plus post #199 was an entirely useless, and possibly false, hypothetical which I'm reading as a sign of desperation, and the entirely shallow defenses and/or baseless threats (like posts #176, #183, #231, #260), which are also signs of desperation.
I don't actually know you well enough to know if this is common with you, but that's certainly suspect in my book.

Long story short, you're either scum or a liability.
 
I do not think ATPG should die. Unvote. As the only other real option is vote: gone3thecelt, so here he goes
 
People, lynching Celt for self-voting is like lynching Pizza for posting a lot. Celt ALWAYS self votes, and Pizza ALWAYS posts a lot (which is a good thing, since he is actually contributing).
 
Then vote: Double A it is, to counter the pizzawagon and to try to flush out a scum.
 
And what about nice, clean cultists?
 
I'm not entirely sure, but I think vote: Double A tried to convert me last night and failed.

Kennigit actually approached me yesterday claiming SW town because he figured there was a 50/50 chance of me being the same. After some deliberation, I revealed to him that I am, in fact, LOTR town, because town infighting is incredibly stupid at this point in the game and I'll either die really early or at the very end of the game. I was still willing to assist him with whatever because I never network unless someone bugs me first, though I didn't exactly make that clear.

He also said this, which I glossed over at first due to being short on time:
"regardless, I am contemplating simply saying "XYZ tried to convert me last night, vote: XYZ" in the thread. Regardless of whether or not that is true, it hopefully could make a bandwagon against either me or against that person (most preferably that person). At least 1/2 of people in the thread should be happy with that, as they are either of the opposing cult ("well it's not one of ours!"), some town ("well he isn't a townie!"), or weasels ("We'll trust Kennigit on this one, then lynch Kennigit next lynch if he's wrong!")

Chances are I probably won't hit a star wars town with that."

This is promoting town infighting, so basically I think Kennegit is trying to stir crap up between the towns because he's likely a (lower-value) cultist role OR just really bad at prioritizing. Either way, screw him and his house. vote: Kennegit
 
Back
Top Bottom