pre-release info Shawnee - Exploration Age Civilization Discussion

pre-release info
One of your countrymen, Pekka Hämäläinen, is one of the biggest names in Native American studies right now.
I didn't know that. That's pretty interesting though not surprising. There are interesting similarities between Finns and (some) Natives that are occasionally discussed here - especially Ojibwe.
How dare you leave the Zulus out. ;)
Haha, I suppose Zulus might also be represented (even if I know them only through civ).
 
Do we not have any screenshots from the Shawnee?
Not super surprising that we don't since they're not t e c h n i c a l l y in the base game.
 
Do we not have any screenshots from the Shawnee?
Just this one.
1724355953421.png
 
Do we think that we've seen Serpent Mound in any pics or footage released so far? (Whether in a Shawnee city or elsewhere)
 
Do we think that we've seen Serpent Mound in any pics or footage released so far? (Whether in a Shawnee city or elsewhere)
Nothing obvious that I've seen. The most distinctive building in the Shawnee screenshot is probably the Palace. The red-roofed circular building doesn't look large enough to be a Wonder.
 
I wouldn't call Shawnee obscure, at least no more than the Shoshone or the Cree from previous games. Then again, I'm from the U.S. and are pretty well known by anyone who has paid attention in a US History class.
I also grew up in the US, but the Shawnee aren't as well known as the Cherokee (who are probably the most well-known tribe), Sioux, or Comanche.
The Shawnee are definitely not obscure. They were the most widespread indigenous people in colonial and early Republic times. Their language was the lingua franca everywhere east of the Mississippi. And Tecumseh is probably the most famous individual Native American, though for some unfortunate reasons.
What did he do?
I don't know who Shawnee are either and they most definitely are obscure for us Finns, but that doesn't mean they don't deserve a chance. If all we chose was famous civs in west, Africa would be represent by a single civ, Egypt. I welcome Shawnee partially because if they are "obscure" there is a chance Finland, a less obscure nation, might have a shot, but predominantly because I'm willing to learn about them.
There would also probably be the Zulu, Carthage, and my personal favorite, the Boers.
 
The Shawnee are probably better known in Canada where they were warmly regarded as allies in the War of 1812
 
What did he do?
He tried to establish a Pan-Indian movement. He was a brilliant general, but unfortunately he became a fixation of Manifest Destiny-minded historians who held him up as proof that even a "latter day Alexander the Great" couldn't stop American expansion. He was the only Native American mentioned by Frederick Jackson Turner, whose Frontier Thesis was foundational for American historiography until the mid twentieth century. (Unfortunately his memory as a warrior glosses over that he was, fundamentally, a man of peace who worked hard to avoid war, and I'm glad Civ7 seems to be portraying him as such.)
 
Sure, but I'm assuming that the Shawnee in game would revolve around their involvement against the U.S. in Tecumseh's War and the War of 1812.
And this is why I don’t understand why they’re not a modern era civ. especially since Buganda’s peak was around the same time and they’re a modern civ.

Also, side note, Tecumseh is by far the best looking leader model we’ve seen so far.

For me it’s Tecumseh, Ashoka, then Hatshepsut, then Amina, then Augustus (eek)
 
For me it’s Tecumseh, Ashoka, then Hatshepsut, then Amina, then Augustus (eek)
I'd swap Hatshepsut and Amina and put Ben Franklin after Augustus, but otherwise I concur.
 
I'd swap Hatshepsut and Amina and put Ben Franklin after Augustus, but otherwise I concur.
ah yeah I forgot about Ben Franklin and Confucius.

Neither looks too bad, but they’re definitely not among the best.
 
ah yeah I forgot about Ben Franklin and Confucius.

Neither looks too bad, but they’re definitely not among the best.
And I forgot about Confucius. I'd put him in the middle. Ben...looks really bad. I'm shocked he's the one they have showcasing leaders on the Steam page.
 
And I forgot about Confucius. I'd put him in the middle. Ben...looks really bad. I'm shocked he's the one they have showcasing leaders on the Steam page.
This isn’t fully on-topic, so I’ll stop talking about it in this thread, at least, but Confucius…really doesn’t look like the depictions of him I’m used to. I thought it was Lao Tzu initially lol

anyway, I think one of the first mods I’ll end up downloading is moving the Shawnee to the modern era if Firaxis don’t fix it themselves. Really bizarre that a civ that peaked in the early 1800s is in the exploration era, which is generally said to end with the 7 years war and American Revolution. Especially since the most correlary civ we have at the moment is Buganda, who peaked around the same time.

Idk, i doubt it was intentional, but it almost feels like “they’re natives so they werent in the modern era yet”, or almost as bad, they WANT the progression to be Shawnee -> USA
 
anyway, I think one of the first mods I’ll end up downloading is moving the Shawnee to the modern era if Firaxis don’t fix it themselves. Really bizarre that a civ that peaked in the early 1800s is in the exploration era, which is generally said to end with the 7 years war and American Revolution. Especially since the most correlary civ we have at the moment is Buganda, who peaked around the same time.

Idk, i doubt it was intentional, but it almost feels like “they’re natives so they werent in the modern era yet”, or almost as bad, they WANT the progression to be Shawnee -> USA
I've seen speculation that it's so you can have progression from Shawnee to Haudenosaunee, but I haven't seen that confirmed anywhere.
 
I agree that the timeline doesn't make a ton of sense with Shawnee/Tecumseh/Iroquois League, but I think the fact that Shawnee is an Exploration Age civ, and that the Iroquois League/Six Nations exists currently, makes it likely that the Iroquois will be the successor civ to the Shawnee (who also still exist today, of course. As a former Oklahoman I feel I have to speak up for that fact.)

But the main reason I predict this is that several of Shawnee's bonuses are towards becoming suzerain over city states. Now, much like Egypt evolving into Songhai makes sense* because Egypt encourages you to found settlements on navigable rivers and Songhai then continues to grant bonuses from having done that, I think Shawnee is going to have a direct evolution option that rewards the work put in to befriending independent powers, and I think the Six Nations/Iroquois Confederacy/Iroquois League is a solid way to do that.

*in purely game mechanical terms, I mean. In historical terms it's a lot like morphing Norway into the U.S.S.R. because hey, both cold northern European civs, right? But no need to get into that here.
I've seen speculation that it's so you can have progression from Shawnee to Haudenosaunee, but I haven't seen that confirmed anywhere.
I would say the Haudenosaunee more accurately peaked in the late part of what civ seems to be defining as the exploration age, while the shawnee peaked in the early part of the modern age. I def associate the Haudenosaunee more with the 7 years war and the Shawnee more with the war of 1812, so in my opinion, the Haudenosaunee to Shawnee progression makes more sense than the other way around—I think they should largely be seen as contemporaries though.
 
I would say the Haudenosaunee more accurately peaked in the late part of what civ seems to be defining as the exploration age, while the shawnee peaked in the early part of the modern age. I def associate the Haudenosaunee more with the 7 years war and the Shawnee more with the war of 1812, so in my opinion, the Haudenosaunee to Shawnee progression makes more sense than the other way around—I think they should largely be seen as contemporaries though.
From what we've seen, the boundaries are nebulous, but they've said the boundary between Exploration and Modern is the mid Industrial Era, which is late 19th century in the US. The Sioux are the only Indigenous civ I could see really peaking in the Modern. But yes, in many ways the Shawnee and Haudenosaunee are contemporary. The Shawnee emerged from the Fort Ancient culture around the same time as the Five Nations were founded, and Joseph Brant was Tecumseh's mentor.
 
From what we've seen, the boundaries are nebulous, but they've said the boundary between Exploration and Modern is the mid Industrial Era, which is late 19th century in the US. The Sioux are the only Indigenous civ I could see really peaking in the Modern. But yes, in many ways the Shawnee and Haudenosaunee are contemporary. The Shawnee emerged from the Fort Ancient culture around the same time as the Five Nations were founded, and Joseph Brant was Tecumseh's mentor.
Then I guess my confusion should be more aimed at Buganda, and why they’re a Modern civ, unless Firaxis thinks their peak was when they were colonized by the UK….

not to mention the exploration era time frame is way too big—ppl have said the medieval era is included in it, so is it really spanning 400 CE to 1850? Surely either medieval kingdoms need to be in the antiquity age (which would be weird) or they should end the exploration era at the end of the renaissance.

I’m hoping that we can make up for the clear lack of native progression to the modern era by having a lot of native american options, if nothing else. Coast Salish and Chinook have been on my wishlist for a long time.
 
Then I guess my confusion should be more aimed at Buganda, and why they’re a Modern civ, unless Firaxis thinks their peak was when they were colonized by the UK….

not to mention the exploration era time frame is way too big—ppl have said the medieval era is included in it, so is it really spanning 400 CE to 1850? Surely either medieval kingdoms need to be in the antiquity age (which would be weird) or they should end the exploration era at the end of the renaissance.

I’m hoping that we can make up for the clear lack of native progression to the modern era by having a lot of native american options, if nothing else. Coast Salish and Chinook have been on my wishlist for a long time.
It seems like both ends of the Exploration Age are deliberately murky. They've said both Antiquity and Exploration overlap the Medieval so I'd expect Exploration is meant to be 1000-1850, give or take a couple centuries on the low end and a few decades on the high end.
 
Back
Top Bottom