Phrossack
Armored Fish and Armored Men
- Joined
- Oct 26, 2008
- Messages
- 6,045
I looked at the thread you linked and apparently I responded to it. That response still mostly holds true, except that I eat more meat than meat substitutes these days.I don't know anything about you or your situation, health, or circumstances so my reply here is based just on the two posts in this thread.
For making a difference, what are examples of people who made a difference? Are you expecting to be Thomas Edison or Abraham Lincoln? Is the difference a doctor makes not enough? A volunteer worker? A writer who influences the thinking and personal growth of a few or many readers? Aid workers? If those sorts of things are enough, then are they all out of reach?
I made a thread asking how we can make a difference and got many great ideas, do these things not count enough? If not, is the issue perhaps more of having unrealistic expectations of yourself? And then how come you have such lofty goals? They would be fine if you chased them, but if they just make you more depressed, perhaps they are not great goals to have.
See yungs posts, he seems like a guy who can possibly do big things, but even if he doesn't, it sounds like he truly Enjoys life, knowing all the things you know about it. Now like I said circumstances I'm sure are very different, but perspective is important as well. I know that's a lot to say to someone especially if they had challenges with physical or mental health, however it helps those that do as well. I definitely look at the world like you do (thinking we're doomed) buuuuut why let that ruin everything before it's actually ruined? And again as bad as things seem to get, climate concerns aside, things still just keep getting better for the majority of people. When first worlders largely complain that SJWs or radical feminists are amongst the biggest problems we face, then we really don't have it that bad. And we are not going to really deal with the worst of the climate issues in our lifetime, so while important to empathize and be safe for those who will be affected and future generations, why let that sadness consume our lives?
Meaningful career is tough, mostly the lucky find that most will have to settle paying the bills, but meaningful passions, hobbies, volunteer work, is that not in reach either? I personally have no idea what I'm passionate about, so I relate, but that's not because there isn't meaningful things that we can do out there.
The political chaos won't impact most people, the poor, those with health challenges, certain relations with certain people, sure, but other than the respectability of the system, the system isn't going to fully crash and burn. Sure the rich and corrupt with get richer and more corrupt, but it's not actuallllly going to go fascist and if it does, well we can all take arms up against it and that will solve the making a difference question.
Finding someone, super tough I get it, but I would say this is tied up in everything else. I knew I'd never even want to be someone when I was feeling a similar state to you, and people can tell when we are there, and it's a wall. But if you forget finding someone and focus on the other things, you may be surprised who you might stumble across.
But I'm sure you've heard all this before, and I'm no stranger to a similar perspective, which is why I start these threads, because then I get inspired by the yungs and hobby's and ElMacs and hygros and downtown's and Tims etc. that remind me that, for us first worlders life really isn't that bad and you can really make your own meaning and mark on it.
Suffice it to say I think the issues humanity faces are severe enough that most human activity is either escapism or something quaint.
Well, no offense to the land across the river, but I was really thinking of mountains, streams, and dense forests when I was talking about "semi-wilderness"!I know some pretty cool cats(well, I think they're cool. They'd probably be tornado yokels or something for dillweed media) that live on country lots in IL. Some of them rent, one of them has an affordable mobile up on a permanent foundation. Satellite internet isn't particularly cheap and the ping stinks, but the bandwidth is acceptable. One could work for the department of Ag. Heck, even just passing the Restricted Use Chemicals Applicator Commercial license, then being good at what you do - reduces unneccessary over application. Positive differences in the world are big and small, and the lions share are not respected by society or particularly sexy. Some of them are just cold and hard and windy. But they're still positive.
I don't speak psychology, but this is not "self-pity." This is more despair, or resignation.So you got an ego-ideal you believe can not achieve, and hence choose self-pity. But you can also just change your ego-ideal, because that is not set in stone, and if trapped in a self-pity hole, that is perhaps the most effective route towards change. It comes down to checking and reconsidering the assumptions which make your frame. And you need one, which brings you to the moment and makes you do things. Which gives you energy, makes you stronger. Which works. You have one which seems to not work. That is a choice. You just need to realize this.
I sound like a motivational couch. Embarrassing. But that is just psychology 101, really. That is the reason therapy can actually work.
I'd also be very careful about giving out psychological advice - it rarely goes over well. Especially lines like "You just need to realize this."
not doing it is a guaranteed non-cure.
Yeah, my issues are generally a bit bigger than "I don't like my job" or "I'm lonely." More like, "Wow, the situation's so bad that all possible actions seem like a waste of time."I mean, sure. And I'm on record ragging against Phrossack elsewhere. But "Just be someone different, bro." as legitimate advice is pretty much hippie woo sold to you by the establishment. Structural issues converted to matters of individual effort and perspective, where the problem is how you look at it instead of what "it" actually is. Perspective does matter greatly, yet reducing an existential issue like Phrossack's to mere decision-making is a bit of a laugh.
I'm trying not to go into specifics. When I do, half the posters, well-meaning or not, turn into amateur psychologists trying to "fix" me with their unsolicited advice based on misunderstandings about my life. So it's best for me to stay vague.Some of it probably is though.
E.g. he wants to have a carrer, but then says it's not achievable. Yet you don't see any specifics about it. I am sure a decision (like what exactly to do, or a commitment to an idea) is missing there, which would probably solve a part of the issue.
Pretty much - and you weren't too much of a dick to me, no worries!Well, he pinpointed the issue rather clearly. There are things he can pursue that he's interested in, but the impact factor is too low to motivate. Self-motivation, when you've been compromised, is difficult to produce, and even the best therapy in the world won't change a thing unless the mind considers something worth motivating for. When your view of the world suggests that it is fundamentally broken beyond repair, a personal change of perspective can fall flat or even feel like willful ignorance.
Which is why even when I've been a dick to Phrossack I try not to change his view of the world and instead only his view of himself. He sees the two as intrinsically connected, which is maybe true depending on how you approach it, but IMO him not considering himself to be human garbage is a better pursuit than trying to argue that the world is his oyster and he need only reach out and claim it, and all he needs to do to make that happen is flip a switch and be happy/motivated.
Yes. If you're "neurotypical," lacking or not being optimized in how you live is fine or, at worst, a new year's resolution that can be broken in February without any fanfare. If you are broken in some way, anything less than total optimal living is a heinous judgement of your worth and is only indicative of personal failure. The system is always working as intended. If you are unsatisfied, upset, or aimless, it is only because you yourself are the problem.
The bolded is especially accurate. I'm pretty anhedonic these days - barely able to register pleasure or happiness. And this does a lot more than simply preventing me from having good days - happiness and other emotional rewards are what's behind a lot of effort and curiosity. I can't be bothered to try new things, or learn new things, or even research some things I already find interesting because I no longer feel that little excitement, joy, or revelation when I accomplish or learn something. The joy of discovery drives us to learn, the sense of achievement drives us to achieve, and I no longer feel either very often. It's like eating your favorite meal when you have such a cold that you can't taste it. You know you should enjoy it, you might eat the food anyway, but the joy is gone, replaced with increasingly fuzzy memories of how it used to be.
And when I so strongly believe things are broken beyond any possibility of repair, basically all human activity starts to look like either escapism, or like a child trying to put out a raging house fire with a tiny squirt gun, thinking they're making a difference. I almost have to marvel at how precious it is. So I question everything with, "What's the point?" And normally the answer is, "There isn't one, really." That sucks the motivation out of me.
That's why what I want out of life now is to kill time for another 15-20 years.