New leader elimination

Did anyone calculate how many votes it takes at minimum to find a winner? With less than 10 posters a day, iI guess it's over a year.
 
Did anyone calculate how many votes it takes at minimum to find a winner? With less than 10 posters a day, iI guess it's over a year.
I agree with Siptah--too many choices spoil the broth in this case.

It would also help to have some handy Internet research links for each leader (whether a news article, encyclopedia article, or the like) so we don't have to Google search every single leader manually.
 
I agree with Siptah--too many choices spoil the broth in this case.

It would also help to have some handy Internet research links for each leader (whether a news article, encyclopedia article, or the like) so we don't have to Google search every single leader manually.
...or a Wikipedia article about them, especially given that much of them are rather obscure historical figures.
 
Did anyone calculate how many votes it takes at minimum to find a winner? With less than 10 posters a day, iI guess it's over a year.
@Siptah, I agree. I'll remove one leader for each civ (one of the ones that hasn't been voted for) and decrease the number of starting votes for each leader to 10. I'm looking at you, Philip - you're on thin ice.
It would also help to have some handy Internet research links for each leader (whether a news article, encyclopedia article, or the like) so we don't have to Google search every single leader manually.
@Morningcalm, If you go to the first page, if you click on any leader's name it takes you to a link about them. I thought of that too.;)
 
Have fun with your new shortened vote template!
Or don't. Maybe take it personally and start a fifteen-page-long argument ...:devil:

:joke:

Thomas Jefferson 10
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
Pedro I 4
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 11
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 10
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 11
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 10
Casmir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 10
Constantine 12
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 7
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10
Shulgi 10
Philip II 1
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Thomas Jefferson 10
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
Pedro I 4 - 3 = 1 Terrible ruler. Who will strike the final blow?
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 11 + 1 = 12 Naval China would be sweet.
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 10
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 11
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 10
Casmir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 10
Constantine 12
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 7
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10
Shulgi 10
Philip II 1
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Thomas Jefferson 10
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
Pedro I 1-3=-2 (ELIMINATED) - Incompetent ruler completely overshadowed by accomplishments of his son, Pedro II, who was also the best leader in Brazilian history. Also, second leader of Brazil would be kind of redundant now. Brazil is one of the Civs that are in low need of another leader.
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 12
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 10
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 11+1=12 - He was the man responsible for the creation of Taj Mahal. Enough said.
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 10
Casmir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 10
Constantine 12
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 7
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10
Shulgi 10
Philip II 1
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Thomas Jefferson 10
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 12 + 1 = 13 Sending a Treasure Ship (replacing the Caravel) to a city-state would increase the trade route slot by 1 and adds an envoy to that city-state; can be done once per city-state
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 10
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 10
Casmir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 10
Constantine 12
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 7
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10
Shulgi 10
Philip II 1 - 3 = ELIMINATED Too confusing with Phillip II of Spain already being in the game
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
:lol:
upload_2017-7-17_13-26-5.png
 
Last edited:
Thomas Jefferson 10
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 13
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 10-3=7 - I'd say that his niche is taken by Pericles in Civ 6
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 10+1=11 - the first king of Poland, strong and agressive ruler who made a lot of territorial gains - and pissed off all the neighbours xD
Casmir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 10
Constantine 12
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 7
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10
Shulgi 10
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Thomas Jefferson (10+1)=11 A decent alternate for a 2nd American leader, if you don't want to bring back ol' George.
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 13
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 7
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 11
Casimir III 10 Wasn't Casimir III already a Civ leader (in Brave New World)?
Marcus Tullius Cicero 10
Constantine 12
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus (7-3)=4 Insignificant
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10
Shulgi 10
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
@Morningcalm, If you go to the first page, if you click on any leader's name it takes you to a link about them. I thought of that too.;)
Ah good. I didn't notice the underlining, or know it led to links at first. Good to see that's clearer.

Thomas Jefferson 11
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 13
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 7
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 11
Casimir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 10 - 3 = 7 (Not a leader in any meaningful way except via oratory.)
Constantine 12
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 4
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10 + 1 = 11 (A capable ruler who died in glorious combat and was immortalized by his people in an epic (which fits the Sumeria civ bonus), Ur-Nammu (Ancient Encyclopedia link) also created a legal code earlier than Hammurabi's)
Shulgi 10
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Last edited:
Ur-Nammu 10 + 1 = 11 (A capable ruler who died in glorious combat and was immortalized by his people in an epic (which fits the Sumeria civ bonus), Ur-Nammu also created a legal code earlier than Hammurabi's)
Ur-Nammu's name would later be used by Marvel Comics for an extra-dimensional demon lord as "Dormammu," made famous in Doctor Strange, when the titular character trapped Dormammu in a time loop.
 
Thomas Jefferson 10
James Madison 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzatl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 13
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 11-3=8 I Don't like having modern leaders in Civilization, you may disagree with me about this.
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 10
Epaminondas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 10
Casimir III 10
Marcus Tullis Cicero 10
Constantine 12+1=13 Constantine was one of the most influential people in all of history. Probably has had the most influence on world history than anyone else on the list.
Yaroslavl II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 7
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 10
Shulgi 10
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Hamilton321 skipped some votes. Here are current scores.

Thomas Jefferson 11
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 13
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 18
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 7
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 11
Casimir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 7
Constantine 13
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 4
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 7
Ur-Nammu 11
Shulgi 10
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Thomas Jefferson 11
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 13
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 9 (8 + 1) I do.
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 7
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 11
Casimir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 7
Constantine 13
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 4
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 4 (7 - 3) Someone better save you, Naypole~
Ur-Nammu 11
Shulgi 10
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Thomas Jefferson 11
James Monroe 10
Mu'awiya 10
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 10
Robert Menzies 10
Acamapichtli 10
Ahuitzotl 10
Juscelino Kubitschek 10
King Wu of Zhou 10
Yongle 13
Rameses III 10
Khufu 10
Elizabeth I 10
Elizabeth II 9
Cardinal Richelieu 10
Henry IV 10
Otto IV, Holy Roman Emperor 10
Wilhelm II 10
Solon 7
Epimonidas 10
Shah Jahan 12
Shivaji 11
Meiji 10
Kanmu 10
Alvaro I 10
Nkumbi a Mpudi 10
Harald V 10
Eric Bloodaxe 10
Boleslaw I 11
Casimir III 10
Marcus Tullius Cicero 7
Constantine 13 + 1 = 14 Very influential person, and would be a great addition to the game.
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 10
Ateas 10
Palacus 4
Alfonso II 10
Joseph Bonaparte 4 - 3 = 1 Basically not a ruler and didn't do anything to deserve it. Waterloo for Napoleon, CivFanatics Forums for Joseph. Who will strike the final blow?
Ur-Nammu 11
Shulgi 10
Caranus 7
Shapur II 11
Nader Shah 11
 
Back
Top Bottom