Winter 2006 Unit makers challenge: jury thread

[Flamand]

The first Unit makers challenge is finished! 7 new organic units were submitted and now it is time for all of you to be the jury...

Who will win? You decide...



Hikaro Takayama - Chocobo Knight

utahjazz7 - Medieval-type Archer

Sword Of Geddon - Gurka

LizardmenRule - Stormvermin guard

Flamand - Cylon centurion

Supa - Mothra

R8XFT - Iceni Battleaxe

 

[The Last Conformist]

No poll?

Anyway, I like utahjazz7's best.

 

[Flamand]

You were too quick. Poll is added...

 

[WildWeazel]

Me too.
The Chocobo was a close second though.

Flamand, are you planning anything for the winner? Like an award graphic?

 

[Flamand]

Good idea... What kind of graphic do you suggest?

 

[Dark Sheer]

Downloading all units to take a look before I cast my vote (A good excuse to download more units eh?)

 

[Supa]

Can participants vote ?

 

[El Justo]

my vote goes to Supa for that Mothra unit. very kewl colors there!

 

[Stormrage]

Dammit! What to choose, what to choose... Oh, well, sorry guys, but for me FF still comes first, so its the Chocobo Knight! Wark!

 

[Goldflash]

This is hard.

The Chocobo is very well animated, however it was mearly asemebled form exisiting parts. Still though, its rather orignal. Um, maybe. Well, okay its nor Original but its um.. good word.

Utahjazz unit is an archer, and from what I undrstard archers are hell to do. A great model, if not a bit simple. But simple isn't nessicarly bad.

Swoggy's unit has style. Its great... except for the exclusion of a muzzle flash. I'd vote for it, but its incomplete. Sorry, swoggy.

LizardmenRule's Unit looks like it was modled, but actually its a cnp unit. That onle might get it my vote. I really respect thoes CnP guys.

Flamand's Cylon is real stiff looking. But thats how they walked in that stupid and terrible television show.

Supa's Mothra is probably the best animated of the bunch.

And finally RT8XFT's axewoman. I think I'm married to her, or atleast her sister.

Oi. This is hard.

 

[Bluemofia]

Hikaro's knight is original, and detailed, but the attack B animation's a bit stiff looking. (3rd place)

If I could vote a second time, Supa's Mothera unit would get my next vote. Really detailed, and animated great. (2nd place)

utahjazz7's archer looks really nice. Very detailed, and the fidget animation looks really good. (1st place, gets the vote)

 

[Storm Grunt]

Wow, this was tough! All the units are Great guys! awesome work......

For me it came down to supas mothra and flamands cylon.The detail, animation,and originality of mothra is tops, but in the end I went with the one that I could best use in one of my mods,so my vote went to the cylon.His movements reflect the old T.V show perfectly...I loved that stupid show

 

[LMR]

How about this?

 

[woodelf]

I have to go with the Chocobo. That unit makes me want to Mod something just to add it!

 

[Flamand]

That looks nice, Lizardman... I'll use it...

 

[Mirc]

The Medieval archer looks best IMHO.

 

[Heretic_Cata]

I can't make up my mind - i won't vote

 

[utahjazz7]

I can't make up my mind - i won't vote

I think you've been reading your signature too much.

 

[Rob (R8XFT)]

I'm glad to see people are voting....and although I'm a bit behind in the race, I'm actually thrilled to bits that I've received the odd vote. There are some really good units up for the vote and this is possibly a better gauge of what people actually like than the request threads.

Perhaps we should do a challenge for leaderheads too !!

 

[Heretic_Cata]

I think you've been reading your signature too much.

I like to many of those units and i can't make up my mind.
But i will vote for the person with the least number of votes
(or maybe i already did).

EDIT: Hurray! - 500 posts