New leader elimination

[Guandao]

James Monroe 13
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Acamapichtli 4
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 21
Ramesses II 14
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Meiji (8-3)=5 Not a big fan of what happened during his reign in Japan, which would lead up to the Japanese Empire, he is like Victoria being a figurehead in front of more powerful men.
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 11
Constantine 23
Yaroslavl II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 7+1=8 I assume he's Alfonso I of Aragon, so he was one of that Kingdom's greatest kings, worthy of being in a mod
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[RFormica]

James Monroe 13
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Acamapichtli 4 - 3 = 1 Didn't do anything significant
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 21 + 1 = 22 Naval China!
Ramesses II 14
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Meiji 5
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 11
Constantine 23
Yaroslavl II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 8
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[Kimiimaro]

James Monroe 13
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Acamapichtli 1-3=-2 (ELIMINATED) - I'm actually not very interrested to see a second leader for Aztecs. Bye!
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 22+1=23 - A fine new choice for a new Chinese leader. Also, naval China!
Ramesses II 14
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Meiji 5
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 11
Constantine 23
Yaroslavl II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 8
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[Guandao]

James Monroe 13
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 23
Ramesses II 14
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Meiji 5-3=2 Not keen on seeing a Meiji mod (Industrial Japan is not my favorite era of Japanese history), plus JFD will probably create one later.
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 11
Constantine 23
Yaroslavl II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I (8+1)=9 Voting him up, since he seems to be a significant Aragonese King.
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[God of Kings]

James Monroe 13
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 10
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 23
Ramesses II 14 + 1 = 15 Amanitore needs someone to keep her in check
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Meiji 2 - 3 = ELIMINATED Mod or not, it's not a leader that needs to be added ASAP
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 11
Constantine 23
Yaroslavl II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 9
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[Hamilton321]

James Monroe 13
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 10-3=7 I like most of the leaders on the list, I believe Al-Mansur has already appeared in civ and I don't think that anyone will miss him.
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 23
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 11
Constantine 23+1=24 As much as I like Yongle, I like Constantine just slightly more.
Yaroslavi II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 9
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[Vahnstad]

James Monroe 13 - 3 = 10 not interesting, we have enough american leaders
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 7
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 23
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 11 + 1 = 12 Good leader. Poland needs more attention.
Constantine 24
Yaroslavi II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 9
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[RFormica]

James Monroe 10 + 1 = 11 Are you kidding me? This guy was great! It would be easy to make an agenda, ability and unique ability for him (And I don't think that 1 vanilla leader and 3 modded leaders is too much for any civ.)
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 7 - 3 = 4 Very good. But not as good as anyone else on this list.
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 23
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 10.... aaand Yaroslav II stays at a solid 10, unchanged since the beginning. (Yaroslav is very happy that there isn't a war over him, like Thomas Jefferson and Shah Jahan.)
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 12 --- removed @Homusubi 's downvote because of confusioin with Alfonso I of Kongo
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11

 

[Kimiimaro]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 4
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 23+1=24 - One of the greatest Chinese emperors, hands down. Yongle encyclopedia could create some great bonus. Naval China is great option for his bonus, too.
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 10
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 12
Ur-Nammu 22
Shapur II 11-3=8 - Shapur II was a great leader, but he is mostly known for his wars, and Cyrus is already a leader who has bonuses in war. Also, I don't think that second Persian leader is really necessary right now.

 

[Morningcalm]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 4
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 24
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 10 - 3 = 7 (Not much information about this guy, and unfortunately his accomplishments don't seem significant enough.)
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 12
Ur-Nammu 22 + 1 = 23 (The game has few ancient leaders, and his accomplishments carry both heavy historical and legendary weight.)
Shapur II 8

 

[Guandao]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur (4+1)=5 He's basically the real founder of the Abbasid Caliphate, with his basic legacy being the city of Baghdad. Plus he has never appeared in Civ before, that's Ahmad al-Mansur (who is the leader of Morocco, not Arabia)
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 24
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II (7-3)=4 Not enough is known of him to pique my interest
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 12
Ur-Nammu 23
Shapur II 8

 

[Kimiimaro]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 5
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 24
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 4
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 12
Ur-Nammu 23+1=24 - He is worthy enough to have most points along with Constantine and Yongle.
Shapur II 8-3=5 - Mostly known for his wars, and Cyrus the Great is already a leader that has some war bonus.

 

[RFormica]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 5
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek
Yongle 24 + 1 = 25 Naval China! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 4
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 12
Ur-Nammu 24
Shapur II 5 - 3 = 2 Same as everyone else

 

[God of Kings]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 5
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek
Yongle 25 + 1 = 26 Naval China + encyclopedia + even returning castrated boys from the Ryukyus
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 12
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 4
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 12
Ur-Nammu 24
Shapur II 2 - 3 = ELIMINATED Same as all the above

 

[KoubaK]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 5
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek
Yongle 26
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 9 (12-3 ... Too many English Monarchs)
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 4
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 13 (12+1 ... what can I say? It's my people lol)
Ur-Nammu 24

 

[RFormica]

12-3 ... Too many English Monarchs

This Henry is French.

 

[Morningcalm]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 5
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek
Yongle 26 Way too high at the moment in my estimation. I also don't think a naval China would be that fun to play. The naval civs in game already are not particularly amazing. Maybe if he started with some bonus like knowing the rough outline of a random continent or something...
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 9 + 1 = 10 (Upvoted for progressive social record and pragmatic political approach, and also to offset KoubaK's incorrect identification. (In future it might help to bracket the nation next to the leader, i.e. "Henry IV (France)". )
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II 4
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 13 - 3 = 10 (Seems more like a Great General than a leader in the administrative, economic and cultural sense, and I don't know what kind of bonus he could get in-game really. Definitely a badass, but he had significant military defeats as well.)
Ur-Nammu 24

 

[Guandao]

James Monroe 11 Besides Monroe Doctrine, I know little about Monroe's Presidency, anyone willing to give me the basics?
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur (5+1)=6 Creator of Baghdad, maybe adds a more productive side to Arabia?
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11 restored JK's score
Yongle 26
Ramesses 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 10
Shah Jahan 9
Shivaji 14
Kanmu 13
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24
Yaroslav II (4-3)=1 Prefer Alexander Nevsky to him as a mod leader for Russia
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 10
Ur-Nammu 24

 

[Hamilton321]

James Monroe 11
Mu'awiya 9
Al-Mansur 6
Henry Parkes 12
Robert Menzies 11
Ahuitzotl 12
Juscelino Kubitschek 11
Yongle 26
Ramesses II 15
Khufu 11
Cardinal Richelieu 13
Henry IV 10
Boleslaw I 14
Casimir III 12
Constantine 24+1=25
Yaroslavl II 1-3=-2 eliminated
Alexander Nevsky 12
Alfonso I 10
Ur-Nammu 24

 

[Hamilton321]

I believe Henry IV was the first Bourbon king of France, though I may be wrong.